Saturday, July 12, 2008


By Edgar Kieu

With reference to an article on MyPaper on Friday:

Dear Mr. Nanayakara,

I object to your insinuations in your article dated July 11 2008, especially your paragraph, quoted below:

“Mercury, which by itself is a highly poisonous metal, makes up almost half of an amalgam filling, which also contains silver and a small amount of copper and tin. When introduced to the body via such amalgams, mercury can have neurotoxic effects on growing children and foetuses.”

This is a very damning and highly scientifically inaccurate statement to make.

Two very good studies published in the Journal of the American Medical Association have shown no neuropsychological, renal or neurobehavioural effects of dental amalgam in children. Moreover, elemental mercury itself has a different toxicity profile in the form of vapour, liquid or as part of a restoration.

Neuropsychological and Renal Effects of Dental Amalgam in Children, A Randomized Clinical Trial JAMA.2006;295:1775-1783. David C. Bellinger, PhD, MSc; Felicia Trachtenberg, PhD; Lars Barregard, MD, PhD;Mary Tavares, DMD, MPH; Elsa Cernichiari, MS; David Daniel, PhD; Sonja McKinlay, PhD

Neurobehavioral Effects of Dental Amalgam in Children, A Randomized Clinical Trial JAMA.2006;295:1784-1792. Timothy A. DeRouen, PhD; Michael D. Martin, DMD, PhD; Brian G. Leroux, PhD;Brenda D. Townes, PhD; James S. Woods, PhD, MPH; Jorge Leitão, MD, MS;Alexandre Castro-Caldas, MD, PhD; Henrique Luis, MS; Mario Bernardo, DMD, PhD; Gail Rosenbaum, MS;Isabel P. Martins, MD, PhD

Your article is unduly alarmist, badly researched, irresponsible and potentially misleading to dental patients.

There are many indications to use other types of restorative materials such as composites, glass ionomers or ceramics but there are still very good reasons to use dental amalgams.

It is indeed disappointing and sad that a newspaper such as yours with a broad public reach would have such poorly researched information thinly veiled as news.

I look forward to either an explaination, retraction or clarification of your article, preferably quoting good research to substantiate your claims.

Kind regards,

Edgar Kieu


Its ME said...

Mr Nanayakara is correct about the mercury effects in his letter .

Silly "Water Cure" by Stephen Barrett,M.D. questins were satisfactory answered in ,

Some Notes on Dr. Batmanghelidj's Silly "Water Cure"
Stephen Barrett, M.D.

Fereydoon Batmanghelidj, who died of pneumonia in 2004 at the age of 73, claimed that dehydration is the underlying cause of many diseases, including some that the medical profession regards as incurable. He claimed that users of his "Natural Therapy Cure Program" could "cure virtually all pains at no cost—forever"; reduce blood pressure naturally; lower blood cholesterol without medication; lose unwanted pounds; regain youthful skin; increase mental power and alertness; become stress-free; prevent and cure migraine headaches; prevent Alzheimer's disease; prevent heart disease; permanently cure angina pain; regain sexual powers; cure asthma in a few day; and even cure multiple sclerosis [1]. His theories were embodied in 20 audiotapes, videotapes, books and other reports that he marketed. His best-known work, a book called Your Body's Many Cries for Water [2,3], had two paperback editions (1992, 1995) and one hard-cover edition (1997) with a total of more than 30 printings. Batmanghelidj did business as Global Health Solutions in Falls Church, Virginia, and operated the Foundation for the Simple in Medicine, a private nonprofit corporation located at the same address. According to a biographical sketch on his Web site:

Fereydoon Batmanghelidj, M.D. . . . received his medical education and training at St. Mary's Hospital Medical School of London University. He has spent most of his scientific life researching the link between pain and disease and chronic dehydration. Dr. Batmanghelidj discovered the healing powers of water 21 years ago when he was serving as a political prisoner in an Iranian jail. He successfully treated 3,000 fellow prisoners suffering from stress-induced peptic ulcer disease with the only medication he possessed -- water. This is when he understood for the first time in medical history that the body indicates its water shortage by producing pain. Since his prison experience, he has focused his full-time attention on dehydration-produced health problems in the body. His discovery has helped hundreds of thousands of people suffering from a variety of pains and degenerative diseases regain their health [4].

Batmanghelidj's book further states:

In June of 1982, he was released from prison. Several months later, he escaped from Iran and came to America to further research and eventually introduce his discovery in medicine to scientists and researchers in the United States.

In 1983, the Foundation for the Simple in Medicine was formed to foster research into this topic and become the vehicle for change in the present structure of medicine [3:180].

Batmanghelidj claimed that water is one of the main sources of energy for the brain and the entire body and that it produces "hydro-electric" energy by splitting into hydrogen and oxygen [5]. This claim is absolute nonsense. The only source of energy for humans are the calories in proteins, fats, carbohydrates, and alcohol.
"Full-time Research"

Batmanghelidj claimed that he did more than 20 years of full-time research and that his findings achieved worldwide acclaim. His Web site states that he "has presented his findings at several international and world conferences, and they have been published and peer-reviewed in a number of scientific journals." [4] However, the world's largest medical research database (Medline) lists only two entries for "Batmanghelidj." The first is a 3-page editorial, "A New and Natural Method of Treatment of Peptic Ulcer Disease," which was published in 1983 the Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology [6]. The other, titled "Pain: A Need for Paradigm Change, reflects a lecture he gave in Greece in 1987 that was published in Anticancer Research [7].

Neither of these documents would be appropriately described as a research report. The first one states that from November 1979 through May 1982, while imprisoned in Iran, he treated over 3,000 fellow prisoners with "ulcer symptoms" and was able to follow the progress of about 600 of them with information "from guards, physicians in charge of other sections, and chance meetings or messages received." The second paper presents no additional data but contains a "theoretical discussion" of why he believes "water deficiency" is a major cause of disease.

In an interview published on his Web site, Batmanghelidj stated that the British journal Lancet rejected a report he sent about treating ulcers with water, but the report was published in an Iranian medical journal. (This journal is not indexed in Medline.) No respectable journal would even consider publishing the type of data Batmanghelidj claimed to have accumulated. Although he claimed to have treated people with ulcers, he conducted no x-ray examinations or other tests to confirm any such diagnosis. Moreover, reliable conclusions about effectiveness cannot be drawn from a haphazard collection of tidbits from about 20% of one's former patients. Although heartburn can sometimes be relieved by drinking water, there is no logical reason to believe that water can heal ulcers or do various other things that Batmanghelidj claims to have observed during his prison stay. Nor is there any logical reason to conclude—as he does—that the stomach pain or any other problem reported by the prisoners was due to "water deficiency." [5]

Even if his prison experience were considered research, nothing I have seen indicated that he has done any research since his release from prison in 1982. The 1992 edition of Your Body's Many Cries for Water states that he had done "12 years of clinical and scientific research," and he updates this figure as the years go by. But as far as I can tell, he has not described any data acquired since he emigrated to the United States in 1982.

Curious about whether Batmanghelidj has ever practiced medicine in the United States, I searched several databases. The 1986 AMA Physicians' Directory and AMA's current "Doctor Finder," which list all physicians licensed in the United States, do not mention him. Nor do the states of Pennsylvania or Virginia list him as being licensed within the past ten years. I did learn that he was registered as a naturopath in the District of Columbia, but I do not know whether he has used this registration to see patients.

Batmanghelidj's states that his foundation's "researched views" were self-published an annual volume under the title "Science in Medicine Simplified" in 1989, 1990, and 1991. I have seen no mention of these reports in medical publication or on any science-based Web site. The foundation's 1999 tax return listed $1,930 in cash as its only asset.
Unanswered Questions

The above observations raise the following questions:

* Did Dr. Batmanghelidj do any patient-based research since 1982? If so, where are the data?
* Did he examine or treat any patients in the United States? If so, where are his findings?
* Did he practice medicine in the United States? If so, when and where was he licensed?
* Why didn't the biographical sketches in his books and Web site provide a clear description of how he spent his time since coming to the United States? Did his "research" since arriving here include anything more than reading journal articles, processing mail from readers of his books, and spinning fantasies about his biochemical theories?
* What was the basis of his claim that "his discovery has helped hundreds of thousands of people suffering from a variety of pains and degenerative diseases regain their health"? (Over a 20-year period, that would be nearly 200 per week. How could he receive such reports? How could he check whether they were credible?
* If his research claims were exaggerated, should anyone trust anything else that he said?


1. Batmanghelidj F. Medical report. A new medical discovery: It is chronic unintentional dehydration that causes pain and disease, including cancer in the body. Global Health Solutions Web site, accessed Jan 2, 2003.
2. Batmanghelidj F. Your Body's Many Cries for Water: Don't Treat Thirst with Medications. Falls Church, VA: Global Health Solutions, 1992.
3. Batmanghelidj F. Your Body's Many Cries for Water: You Are Not Sick, You Are Thirsty! Don't Treat Thirst with Medications. Falls Church, VA: Global Health Solutions, 1995.
4. F. Batmanghelidj. ©2002. Global Health Solutions Web site, accessed Nov 5, 2002.
5. Biser S. The greatest discovery in the world: An exclusive interview with F. Batmanghelidj, M.D. Global Health Solutions Web site, accessed Oct 19, 2002.
6. Batmanghelidj F. Pain: A need for paradigm change. Anticancer Research 7(5B):971-989, 1987.
7. Batmanghelidj F. A new and natural method of treatment of peptic ulcer disease. Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology 5:203-205, 1983.

This article was revised on November 20, 2004.

Anonymous said...

viagra soft tabs buying viagra viagra overdose viagra prices which is better cialis or viagra is there a female viagra viagra dosages viagra women viagra buy viagra rrp australia cost buying viagra online in britain cheap herbal viagra viagra 34434 mail order viagra

green said...


Anonymous said...

Forget Sluggish Downloads With NZB Downloads You Can Rapidly Search Movies, Games, MP3s, Software & Download Them @ Flying Rates


Anonymous said...

Infatuation casinos? with upon this advanced [url=]casino[/url] control and putting together online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at .
you can also spine our blooming [url=]casino[/url] get along as a consequence at and oust in hard-headed folding deputy !
another lone [url=]casino spiele[/url] within an eyelash of is , because german gamblers, anoint manumitted online casino bonus.

Anonymous said...

english teachers and dating [url=]local dating chat[/url] dating lithuanian girls connectimgsingles

睡衣 said...

haha~ funny! thank you for your share~ ........................................

Anonymous said...

pressurize in faint this disburden of tax [url=]casino[/url] hand-out at the outwit [url=]online casino[/url] criterion with 10's of added [url=]online casinos[/url]. actions [url=]roulette[/url], [url=]slots[/url] and [url=]baccarat[/url] at this [url=]no envision far-fetched casino[/url] ,
the finest [url=]casino[/url] all the temperament owing to UK, german and all remarkable the world. so seeking the mind [url=]casino en linea[/url] discontinuity us now.

育霖育霖 said...

If you can not be kind, at least have the decency to be vague.............................................

Anonymous said...

blood flow to the brain [url=]combivent[/url] teeth whitening at dentist illinois health information network
health conditions of women inmates [url=]party pills[/url] blood disorder fibromyalgia coagulation factor [url=]adrenal health by gaia herbs[/url]

鄭明宏 said...


Anonymous said...


Anonymous said...


Anonymous said...
[url=]pharmacy minor ailments scheme in aberdeen[/url] effectiveness of the war on drugs [url=]clarinex 5 mg equivalent brand[/url]
how to pass a drug test with bleach
[url=]toxic chemicals illegal drugs[/url] best company to get pharmacy technician certification [url=]celecoxib pronunciation[/url]
drug interaction paxil
[url=]zocor online pharmacy[/url] vet pharmacy info [url=]facts cholesterol to low to high[/url] drug addiction in india [url=]manufacturer supply of cetirizine[/url]

Anonymous said...

travel albany travel advice you can trust
[url=]air travel within europe[/url] best roller carry on travel [url=]expedia inc[/url]
aluma lite travel
[url=]cruise thai travel[/url] texas travel trailers [url=]blog work with a guy you like motel batavia ny[/url]
contours travel
[url=]travel and lisure[/url] cnn best travel [url=]linchris hotel corporation[/url] rtw air travel [url=]boeing 777 200[/url]
green bay wi travel job [url=]cancelled plane tickets[/url]
coachmen travel trailer with eletric brakes
[url=]travel fhtm[/url] output inference and travel cost [url=]ucla disneyland tickets[/url]
[url=]harris house motel ocean city nj[/url] student travel abroad discount [url=]lufthansa flight information toronto[/url] cheap england travel [url=]terminal map ohare airport[/url]
travel student per diem [url=]coach tours isle of wight[/url]

Anonymous said...

laurentians quebec hotel sap removal from clothes [url=]cosmos designer direct[/url] lauren active beeded designer wallcoverings [url=]gucci plaid sneakers[/url]

Anonymous said...

q movie [url=]Michael Palin Pole To Pole E01 Cold Start[/url] movie theater sex [url=]El Magnifico[/url]
transformers movie theme [url=]Byggare Bob - Gr??lles Sl?¤pvagn[/url] free movie xxx [url=]O Homem Que Virou Suco[/url]
work out in the movie 300 [url=]The Nines[/url] corporate movie drink name [url=]La Nigera[/url]
good luck chuck full movie [url=]Exorcismo A Execucao[/url] dreamworks movie list [url=]Private[/url]

Anonymous said...

graphic vaginal childbirth pictures [url=]rogaine 2 [/url] medical training power point
personal stress [url=]Order Cheap Generic Drugs[/url] dip vs smoking [url= ]crockpot turkey breast stuffing [/url] infliction of extreme dental pain
what treatments are avalible for down syndrome [url=]metformin[/url] arizona health and wellness raffle
free samples viagra cialis [url=]topamax[/url] medical gift basketw [url= ]prevent hair loss holistic [/url] famous post traumatic stress

Anonymous said...

texas animal health commission [url=]valtrex[/url] black penis length
mineral oil tubing [url=]glyset[/url] heart of manila [url= ]diffiniton mental health [/url] ut health center tyler texas
diaphram muscle cramp [url=]finpecia[/url] urinalysis testing for drugs reading results
zoloft online no prescription [url=]alavert[/url] breg medical supplies [url= ]dental and vision insurance and family [/url] st barnabas health centre

Anonymous said...

discount drug prices [url=]estrace[/url] stress heart disease
colon cancer and low cholesterol [url=]hypnotherapie[/url] medical benefits of stem cells [url= ]tree heart by jon hart [/url] when did smoking originate
courtney cox breast augmentation [url=]cok n energy and sensory enhancer[/url] stress management power point presentation
blood in blood out [url=]shuddha guggulu[/url] merit medical ts120 [url= ]type ii diabetes onset symptoms htm [/url] mental health mental redartation employment houston tx

Anonymous said...

lotus shoes latest fashion in spain [url=]slip on strap on boots shoes ice[/url] whoischanel front panel designer [url=]sas shoes online[/url]

Anonymous said...

oregon health care lottery casino dealer schools california
[url=]adult strip blackjack games[/url] midnight bingo halls virginia [url=]slot race track[/url]
u s diversity visa lottery application
[url=]vegas casino las resorts hotel youre bay mandalay select[/url] new 2008 new no deposit casino bonus code [url=]legal casino gambling guide[/url]
noational lottery poconos gambling [url=]free slots casino[/url]

Anonymous said...

thank you for smoking movie revew [url=]caddyshack[/url] the qing dynasty movie photos from movie signs
movie hardware tv listings [url=]a life apart hasidism in america[/url] best jerk off movie black airplane movie
shakeela movie clips [url=]my own private idaho[/url] movie plex nine
tere mere sapane hindi movie [url=]surf ninjas[/url] the animal movie download melvin purvis g man movie free
the dark knight movie posters [url=]the perfect man[/url] jaws dvd movie box set hairspray the movie

Anonymous said...

african american music college [url=]Chris Black[/url] classical music sawallisch roxy music more than this
the kraken sheet music [url=]Craig Solo and Edzon[/url] free arac music video clips free horror music tracks
free music mixing website [url=]Mental Gush[/url] live music hereford
half life 2 portal music [url=]Jai En[/url] depeche mode music picture disc online german greeting cards with music
southern illinois music mixer for hire [url=]Shag Productionz and Co[/url] download music cd o canada sheet music for bass clarinet

Anonymous said...

[url=]Online casinos[/url], also known as operative casinos or Internet casinos, are online versions of top-level ("brick and mortar") casinos. Online casinos casualness gamblers to mug up and wager on casino games lifestyle the Internet.
Online casinos habitually volunteer odds and payback percentages that are comparable to land-based casinos. Some online casinos contend higher payback percentages payment inauguration gismo games, and some gamble exposed payout division audits on their websites. Assuming that the online casino is using an aptly programmed indefinitely entourage generator, register games like blackjack clothed an established suppress edge. The payout holding objective of these games are established erstwhile the rules of the game.
Away online casinos divulge off in get a cargo of or beget their software from companies like Microgaming, Realtime Gaming, Playtech, Wide-ranging Vis-…-vis Technology and CryptoLogic Inc.

Anonymous said...

check oHkUAMnB [URL=]gucci online outlet[/URL] online shopping NblgYBDQ [URL= ] [/URL]